Saturday, July 10, 2010

The iPhone 4 iRony

No, by irony I'm not referring to the metal frame in the antenna design catastrophe that's been causing Steve Jobs to lose a large amount of sleep and hair (?) these days.

<background_info>

For my friends who are blissfully unaware of the happenings in the world of mobile phones, apple has come up with a new upgrade, the iPhone 4. And while it is a great phone, it has a tiny issue: if you hold the phone normally in your left hand, you lose signal receptivity by upto 20dB on average.
This means that your signal bars will all vanish and you'll experience dropped calls if you're not standing.. well.. right next to a tower.

The problem actually arises from the new antenna design of the iPhone. Rather than use an internal antenna that has been built into practically every mobile since the old ugly extendable outer ones have been outdated, Apple chose an exterior one. One that goes round the phone. Yes, outside.




The reason they did this? To improve receptivity.
Ok, there's irony for you. But hang on, that's only part of it.

</background_info>



When the iPhone 4 customers noticed this effect, they did what anyone would do: uploaded videos to youtube, wrote artices, posted on forums, and generally made a hue and cry about it.



Initially Apple had denied the whole design flaw thing, saying that it was just a problem with the way the bars were being shown. Go ahead, read the letter of how the engineers at Apple were "stunned" to discover that their formula was "totally wrong".

Later, when they realized they couldn't get away with that and that the problems were not going away, they admitted the issue in an official statement:
"Gripping any phone will result in some attenuation of its antenna performance with certain places being worse than others depending on the placement of the antennas. This is a fact of life for every wireless phone," Apple said. "If you ever experience this on your Phone 4, avoid gripping it in the lower left corner in a way that covers both sides of the black strip in the metal band, or simply use one of many available cases."
It is true that all phones could have this, but to my knowledge no manufacturer to date has put the ends of the antenna at the lower left corner of a phone where people normally hold it. It could have been placed at the top with no problems whatsoever.


Anyway, now here comes the irony (again).

Below are some frames from the official iPhone promo video (click to expand):





And here are some frames from the iPhone 4 Facetime TV Ad (click to expand):





So?

You're a bit slow? Ok, I'll spell it out for ya.
Apple says "avoid gripping it in the lower left corner in a way that covers both sides of the black strip in the metal band". 

That's how they're all holding it! All the models, in Apple's own promo and TV ad, are holding it that way!
Maybe Jobs doesn't realize: That's how all right handed people hold it!

Hell, that's how you hold it too!


:D



Now if you have time for some real humor, watch this:


Then watch this:


:D :D


Links:

Consumer Reports Lab Tests
Anandtech Lab Test: iPhone 4 Signal Problem
PCMag iPhone Deathgrip Article
CNet News Article on Apple's acknowledgement
iPhone 4 Facetime TV Ad


So what's your opinion on Apple's moronic.. er.. ironic behavior? Comment and let me know..


P.S. Thanks to everyone for the kind words, encouragement and one very inspiring verse (albeit written jokingly) for my previous post, which is the reason for this one being a whole year ahead of schedule.. ;)

Tuesday, July 6, 2010

The best mobile phone in the market? (Part 3 of 3)

Part 3 of 3


Conclusion & Links:

In conclusion, I would say that this phone absolutely rocks. Even if you're someone like me who has never used an HTC before, you'll love it. I am amazed that HTC has become such a quality oriented company. Everything including the packaging, the charger plug and the USB cable just seem to ooze quality.

Did I mention that the phone is blazing fast? No matter how many widgets you have on your homescreens, you'll still get the cool animations when you swish from one screen to another, or view the helicopter view. The only time you'll experience any lag is when you have an application installing in the background. I spend many minutes simply playing with and admiring the screen transition animations. (I know, I know)

Many of you might be wondering how good the phone is for gaming. Frankly I have not tried many high FPS games on this phone yet. But with specs like these, I don't think the Desire is going to face any problems. One of the games I do enjoy is Teeter, which comes pre-installed. It makes use of the nice and sensitive g-sensor to roll a ball around and drop it into the right hole.



The one problem you definitely will have with the phone is the battery life. However, it's not any less than other competing smartphones, so I daresay that no matter which smartphone you go for, battery will always be an issue. The Desire is currently giving me around 20 hours per charge, and I am a very heavy user. If you use the phone just as a phone (no GPS, WiFi, movies), you should get around 1.5 days easily. Still, I feel HTC should have given the Desire at least a 1500 mAh juice-pack instead of just 1400 mAh.


You might have awaken by now to the fact that this is not a complete product review. This was just my attempt as a user to touch upon some commonly overlooked aspects. I'm not even sure whether I've done that or not, and I definitely have not provided an in-depth analysis of anything. If you're considering this as your next phone, you should visit the following links too:

Trusted Review Sites:

Forum:

Apps:



Now I'll be nice and also tell you what the closest competitors to this phone are. In no particular order, they are:

1) Samsung Galaxy S (Awesome on paper, but sadly it's Samsung - hardware rocks, software sucks)

2) HTC Legend (Less features, better looks)


3) Google Nexus One (Almost the same thing)


4) Samsung Wave (Great specs but again, Samsung, and has "Bada" OS - what the crap)


5) iPhone 4 (Great phone, but read its reviews and you'll see numerous comparisons with the Desire where it fails. Also plagued by critical design flaws)



Alright, that's enough typing for a year (check my blog entries, they're that infrequent :P ).

If you're seriously considering buying the phone you will no doubt have several questions. You can post them here as comments and I'll give you my opinions as a user. If you found these posts useful, letting me know that will inspire me to write more in the future.. hehe.. :D

Thanks for reading!

The best mobile phone in the market? (Part 2 of 3)

Part 2 of 3


Interface:

This is the second most important parameter. Wait, it could be the most important one... Hell, they're both extremely important: display and interface.. um.. the display is a part of the interface, anyway.

If you've owned a few handsets before, I'm sure you know how frustrating it is if you have to wait for the phone to catch up with your speed while typing messages, or traversing the menu. How many key presses/touches does it take to operate something? If it's too many, you'll be peeved, I guarantee.

The interface is truly a lovable thing on the Desire. Even your slightest touches are registered; it's like the phone knows what you're thinking. Multi-touch is supported. Yes, it means you can pinch the screen to zoom in and out of photos/websites etc. The smartphone runs on Google's open source Android 2.1 'Eclair' operating system, which is great, for two reasons: availability of thousands of apps to enhance your phone with, and an extremely dedicated community of developers.


The interface is based on something called the HTC Sense, which on this model allows 7 homescreens for ultimate customization. There are innovations like the Friendster widget that integrates Facebook, Twitter and Flickr into a single window, but I'm sure you can read about all that elsewhere. In this blog entry, I'll tell you about things that most smartphone manufacturers miss out on that HTC thankfully hasn't.

While all smartphones claim to be capable of  moving mountains and bringing world peace, they often fail at simple things like dialing and receiving calls, accessing and searching the phonebook, etc. These things are a breeze with the Desire. Although I did find a couple of bugs:
- SMS delivery notification icons don't change from undelivered to delivered
- There's a special option to change a contact's name is displayed in your list, from what they've used on facebook or google, or what you've saved it as on your phone. But intermittently this doesn't work.
- The LED indicator on the top right of the phone blinks when there's a notification like SMS or email, but it blinks only for a few minutes. So if you're away from your phone for a long time, you wont see the notification light.

Apart from these, there are absolutely no flaws. When you are on a call, the proximity sensor on the top left of the screen detects your ear next to it and the touchscreen is automatically turned off to prevent your cheek from messing around with it. This is one problem solved, that I had with my previous touchscreen phone.

There are other things about the interface that shine too, best read a professional review for the entire list.


Messaging:

Yes, you can type messages with one hand.. with your left hand, if need be. Never imagined I'd be able to do this on a touch screen phone. Thank you, you freakishly accurate word prediction-correction system. You don't need to tap on the letters, just any letter in its general vicinity and the phone mind-reads and inserts the correct word for you. Of course, if this isn't awesome enough for you, you can install Swype or Voice recognition. Now, this voice recognition is tweaked for American accents, so it might not do well with others'.




In the messaging app, you have conversation style messages inspired by gmail, which is a refreshing new thing on a phone. Earlier I've had to zip back and forth between the Inbox and Sent Items box to review a conversation.


Browsing:

It wont replace your laptop, but it gets close. I use this thing all the time. You can open several pages at once, although there's a limit to the number of open pages at any one time: it's 4. 
The most interesting feature that throws dirt in the eyes of the other browsers is text reflow.. You pinch and zoom, and the text adjusts into your screen. No matter what the zoom level is. It's fast. It's perfect. It means you don't need to pan left and right to read an article, just scroll down as you would in a normal desktop browser. If you want to view the larger images on the page, you will have to pan, as images are not resized (it's just fine the way it is). 



Youtube can be played on the fly, you can download stuff of course, and there's a lot to be said about the flash support. All page elements are loaded, be it videos or animations. The CEO of HTC does not hate flash.



Music:

My biggest gripe about the built-in music app is that I cannot choose to play individual folders. If you have your MP3 tags in order, you can play tracks from an album, an artist, a genre, and you can make your own playlists. If you lock your phone while playing music, as you would no doubt want to, you can access the music controls from the lock-screen without unlocking. You can control the volume too while locked, just use the volume rocker. If you want to change the track or play/pause without touching the phone, you can do it using the controls on the earphones that are supplied. 



You can do any number of things on the phone while the music is playing, and it will never skip or pause for a microsecond. That's a 1 GHz processor running it, baby, and were talking here of the same class of processors that were in the highest-end Pentium IIIs if you remember those.

When you get a call, the music pauses and when you hang up the music is automatically resumed.. I'm just mentioning these small things because these are what manufacturers normally miss that end up becoming major annoyances.

The speaker is exceptionally loud and clear, and no doubt you will find it one of the best in the market.


Contacts:

First, you have the option of storing your contacts on the phone, sim or google. Yes, google. Choose that one. They'll automatically be synced with your google contacts, and you have a backup there just in case. If you have multiple entries for the same person no problem, you can link them up in the Desire. If you have a person as a friend on facebook, you can link that too, and the phone pulls in the necessary details to fill in your contact card such as birthday and profile pic. This pic is then shown on your screen when that person calls. One small issue here: the pic shown is slightly pixelated, because it's low res. Not something to lose sleep over.


From within the contact card you can see the details (obviously), view SMSes and emails for that contact, view updates and events, view their photos from facebook or flickr, and view detailed call history with that person.

And yes.. You do not need to go into the contacts app to dial a number. You can open up the keypad, and type in the first letters/digits and the contact shows up. eg. tap 3,2 and you get Dad as a suggestion.


This feature was present on my old SE phone, but there are still models out there that don't have this. I wouldn't buy any phone that doesn't, now that I'm used to it. It saves a hell lot of time.


Camera:

It's a 5 megapixel autofocus camera with LED flash. Takes decent photographs, and fast. There's no delay like the old Nokias where you've clicked a photo in a second, and are waiting for 5 for it to be saved to disk. Here the instant you click it, it saves.

I'll have you know I'm a photography enthusiast, so I am quite familiar with cameras and equipment. And I'm not really a fan of mobile photography. Mobile cams can never ever really achieve the kind of quality produced by high end lenses and large sensors.
However, the HTC Desire has one thing that my own $500 photography rig does not: touch focus. You touch on an object on the preview to shift focus onto that. The rest of the pic will be out of focus, and you get a nicely controlled DOF (depth-of-field).


It also has face detection. I have noticed that pictures with flash almost always have a red-eye problem. You can, of course, remove that on a PC, and one really shouldn't expect any more from a mobile camera in my opinion. Smooth zoom is present, and there are several settings that can be tweaked like brightness, contrast, color saturation, and sharpness. You can choose your metering mode (how the cam chooses exposure). There are a few effects that you can apply beginning with grayscale and sepia. You can also easily geotag your photos with your location.

Video capture feature is present, but I haven't taken a single video yet so I won't go into that. HD recording is not supported.


Reception & Call Clarity:

The Desire is a mobile phone after all, and one might be mildly interested in knowing whether it performs that duty well.. Oh yes, it does. Beautifully. Now you may not see as many bars in the signal icon as there are in your Nokia E series, but even with one bar remaining, there was no drop in call quality.

Bear in mind, the usage of bars for signal reception is not standardized and different phones may show different number of bars for the same network strength. I have not done a detailed test by measuring the decibels of network strength, but from what I have felt uptil now the reception is excellent.

The earphone is crystal clear, and the other person heard my voice with perfect clarity too.